Research article / 2025, Vol. 16, No. 1, pages 167-179

167


167

Gastronomic uses of forgotten foods such as chacha fruit and loquat


Usos gastronómicos de los alimentos olvidados como el

chachafruto y el níspero



Authors:


Angie Dávila

Diego GarcíaLeonor M. Pérez

Cafam University Foundation Colombia

Diana Corzo-Barragán

Jardín Botánico de Bogotá, Colombia.

Carina Gutiérrez Paz

Fundación Universitaria Cafam, Colombia

Carlos Carrasco

St. Bonaventure University Bogotá, Colombia.


Corresponding author:


Carina Gutiérrez Paz cgutierrezp@unal.edu.co


Receipt: 02 - January - 2025

Approval: 23 - April - 2025

Online publication: 30 - June - 2025


How to cite this article: Usos gastronómicos de los alimentos olvidados como el chachafruto y el níspero. Maskana, 16(2), 167–179. https://doi.org/10.18537/ mskn.14.02.11


doi: 10.18537/mskn.16.01.11

© Author(s) 2025. Attribution-NonCommercial- ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)


Gastronomic uses of forgotten foods such as chacha fruit and loquat

Usos gastronómicos de los alimentos olvidados como el chachafruto y el níspero


Abstract Resumen


Forgotten foods are species relegated from the gastronomic scene as a consequence of a series of economic, historical and cultural changes that have caused them to be undervalued. The objective of this research was to investigate the uses of the Chachafruto (Erythrina edulis) and the Medlar (Manilkara zapota).

The research was divided into phases: 1. Interviews in market squares in the city of Bogotá seeking to establish the level of knowledge and availability; 2. Physical and bromatological analyses. 3. Application of recipe transformation and standardization techniques. 4. Sensory panel. The results obtained highlight the lack of knowledge of the two species and low availability. Products such as wrappers, chancacas, fritters, pasta, cookies, pickles were generated; which presented a high level of acceptance, evidencing a preference for the consumption of sweet preparations made from Níspero. In conclusion, both species have a high potential to be transformed


Keywords: native foods, endemic species, regional cuisine, gastrobotany

Los alimentos olvidados son especies relegadas del panorama gastronómico como consecuencia de una serie de cambios de carácter económico, histórico y cultural que ha generado que sean subvaloradas. El objetivo de esta investigación fue indagar sobre los usos del Chachafruto (Erythrina edulis) y el Níspero (Manilkara zapota).

La investigación se dividió en fases: 1. Entrevistas en plazas de mercado de la ciudad de Bogotá buscando establecer el nivel de conocimiento y disponibilidad. 2. Análisis físicos y bromatológicos. 3. Aplicación de técnicas de transformación y estandarización de recetas. 4. Panel sensorial.

Los resultados obtenidos, destacan el desconocimiento de las dos especies y baja disponibilidad. Se generaron productos como envueltos, chancacas, buñuelos, pasta, galletas, encurtidos; los cuales presentaron un alto nivel de aceptación, evidenciando una preferencia por el consumo de preparaciones dulces hechas a partir de Níspero. En conclusión, las dos especies cuentan con un alto potencial para ser transformadas.


Palabras clave: alimentos nativos, especies endémicas, cocina regional, gastrobotánica.


Angie Dávila1, Diego García, Diana Corzo-Barragán, Carina Gutiérrez Paz, Carlos Carrasco

  1. Introduction



    The term "forgotten foods" refers to plant spe- cies that have been relegated from the diets of the world's population and, as a consequence of a series of political, historical, environmental, economic, and cultural changes, are in danger of extinction (Global Forum on Agricultural Re- search [GFAR], 2011). These changes over the years have led to the loss of food species world- wide (Gonzales, 2008), which is why organiza- tions such as the Food and Agriculture Organi- zation of the United Nations (FAO), the World Health Organization (WHO), and the Global Forum on Agricultural Research (GFAR), pio- neers in agriculture, nutrition and food security, have allocated resources and efforts for the re- vitalization of undervalued crops. The aim is to preserve the genomes of plant species with high nutritional value, thereby ensuring food security for vulnerable populations, mitigating food shor- tages, and strengthening the economies of small farmers through the trade of these plant species in local markets (GFAR, 2021).


    However, these efforts have been overshadowed by various factors, including the low supply and demand for these foods in the market, as well as a partial lack of knowledge about the gastrono- mic and nutritional value provided by their con- sumption (GFAR, 2021). In Colombia, 22 plant species were recorded until 2019, including fruits and tubers such as Erythrina edulis (cha- cha fruit), Manilkara zapota (loquat), and Hie- ronyma macrocarpa Müll.Arg. (motilón), Chry- sobalanus icaco L. (icaco), Annona cherimola Mill (custard apple), and Annona squamosa L. (anón), just to mention a few examples. These species, due to their low yields or the lack of knowledge among villagers, have seen a gradual decline in production in recent years, as they do not generate significant profits for small produ- cers and farmers. Consequently, they have opted to replace these crops with more commercially viable ones (Alvarez et al., 2019).


    The world's largest seed bank, located in Sval- bard, houses more than 65,000 food species. It

    promotes the cultivation of these plant species in small farming communities through entrepre- neurship and crop substitution programs, which include hundreds of varieties of beans, cassava, and forages, aimed at preventing their extinction and encouraging their consumption (Gonzales, 2022). Other entities, such as the Botanical Gar- den of Bogota (JBB), promote the cultivation and propagation of some undervalued species, which, through research on their benefits, allow the identification of possible uses at the gastro- nomic and industrial level in order to promote their local consumption (Botanical Garden of Bogota, 2022). According to the above, of the 22 plant species identified at the national level, two were selected as the objects of study: the chacha fruit (Erythrina edulis Triana ex Micheli) and the Loquat (Manilkara zapota (L.) P.Royen).


    The chachafruto, also known as balú, nupo, ba- luy, poroto, sachaporoto, jite, frisol calú or frijol de árbol (Acero et al., 1992). It is a native food of South America; its scientific name is Erythri- na edulis, and it belongs to the Fabaceae family.


    Its tree can reach heights of between 14 and 25 meters, and its fruit is spherical, ranging from reddish to brown, depending on its ripening sta- ge. Its average diameter ranges from 2.5 to 7 cm (Molano, 2005). Its cultivation extends along the Andes mountain range in the sub-Andean forest zone (Prieto & Colonia, 2018). Regarding the ancestral uses attributed to chacha fruit, we find its sowing associated with the propagation of co- ffee or lulu crops, as it helps fix nitrogen in soils, an essential nutrient for the cultivation of other plant species. Its consumption as feed for fatte- ning animals is widespread nowadays. However, there are records of its use for the preparation of sancochos, custard, recipes, salads, cakes, cola- das, fried foods, compotes, empanadas, and coo- kies (Acero et al., 1992).


    The loquat, on the other hand, is an exotic fruit; its scientific name is Manilkara zapota, and it belongs to the Sapotaceae family, genus Mani-


    lkara (Royen, 2007), which comprises more than 700 species and over 40 genera. A tree native to the Americas, its growing area is in tropical and subtropical climates at an altitude of 1200 m or less above sea level (Karle Pravin & Dhawale Shashikant, 2019). Its tree can reach 25 to 40 meters in height, and its fruit presents an ovoid or circular shape with a diameter of approxima- tely 6 to 9 cm. Its pulp is fibrous, juicy, sweet, and reddish brown; its peel is brown with a rou- gh texture (Karle Pravin & Dhawale Shashikant, 2019). Each fruit contains 2 to 12 seeds. These have a flat oval shape and a shiny black color, approximately 1 cm in diameter (Carrillo, 2022). It is also known as zapotilla, níspero de monte, níspero de anís, chicle, or chicozapote. Regar- ding its gastronomic uses, it is usually consumed fresh in juices, ferments, jams, and preserves (Buitrago et al., 2004) ). According to figures

    from the Ministry of Health, loquat consump- tion at the national level is 1%; the departments where this fruit is most produced and consumed are Guajira and Atlántico with 2.2% of people, Sucre with 1.4% at the regional level and Mag- dalena with 0.3% (Ministry of Health and Social Protection, FAO, (2013)).


    The purpose of this research was to investigate the gastronomic uses of two vegetable species cataloged as forgotten foods, such as chacha fruit (Erythrina edulis) and Loquat (Manilkara zapota), to apply transformation techniques (de- hydration, addition of sugar, thermal treatments, pH modification, described in the document Transformation and Culinary Preparations of High Andean Species (Torres & Corzo-Barra- gán, 2019), in order to diversify their form of consumption.


  2. Materials and methods



    Species selection


    Two species were identified: Chachafruto (Erythrina edulis) and Níspero (Manilkara zapo- ta). These were selected based on two criteria: first, they were classified as forgotten foods ac- cording to the group of endangered native spe- cies mentioned in the article by Álvarez et al. (2019), and second, their availability in the local capital market.


    Experimental design


    The development of this research was divided into four stages: (1) interviews in marketplaces in Bogotá, and (2)


    1. Interview in marketplaces


      For the development of this stage, a semi-struc- tured interview was used as a data collection instrument with 16 open and closed questions to measure the level of knowledge about the two

      species in question.

      This format enabled the collection of both qua- litative and quantitative data, including knowle- dge of cultivation areas, gastronomic and medicinal uses, memories associated with con- sumption, common names, harvest seasons, and consumption preferences, as well as quantitative data such as the level of knowledge, weekly sa- les in kilograms, frequency of consumption, and sales prices.


      The sampling method was non-probabilistic, in- tentional, or convenience-based and was applied with prior informed consent. A previous survey was conducted among the sales stalls of the se- lected marketplaces to identify the distributors of the selected species. Thus, the interview was conducted with those who attended the sales stalls, comprising a sample of 60 people distri- buted as follows: 17 people at Paloquemao Mar- ket Square, 13 people at Siete de Agosto District Market Square, and 30 people at Las Ferias Dis- trict Market Square.



    2. Physicochemical and bromatologi- cal analyses


      Physicochemical and bromatological analyses were conducted to determine aspects such as Brix degrees, pH, firmness (kg/cm), moisture content (%), total ash, crude protein (g), and fiber percentage, following the procedure des- cribed by Corzo and Plazas (2019). These data were obtained through primary and secondary sources.


    3. Application of food preservation te- chniques and recipe generation.


      For this stage, a total of 18 recipes were selected that obeyed three essential criteria: affinity with applied transformation techniques described in the document transformation and culinary pre- parations of high Andean species (Hernández et al.,2019); classification as high consumption products according to reports from ([ANDI], Asociación Nacional de Empresarios de Colom- bia, 2023) the gastronomic identity associated with the regional cuisines of Colombia ([ANDI], Asociación Nacional de Empresarios de Colom- bia, 2023). These recipes were: capacity negra fritters, envueltos, yogurt, chachalacas, pickled, chutney, arequipe, jam, bocadillo, fruit sauce,


  3. Results


    fruit cheese, flavored oatmeal, bean casserole, frijoles cream, flavored rice pudding, sponged, starch extraction for panders elaboration, com- posite flours for making roscón with a substitu- tion percentage of 15%, Ojo de buey cookie with a substitution percentage of 15%, pasta with a substitution percentage of 50% and buñuelos de Antioquia with a substitution percentage of 50%.


    Angie Dávila1, Diego García, Diana Corzo-Barragán, Carina Gutiérrez Paz, Carlos Carrasco

    2.4. Sensory evaluation in untrained pa- nel


    The first group consisted of 20 children aged 7 to 13 years, for whom a format based on the 5-point facial hedonic scale was used. The second group consisted of 50 visitors to the Botanical Garden of Bogotá, aged between 18 and 65 years, who, after filling out the informed consent form, used the format based on the 5-point mixed hedonic scale, where criteria of taste, aroma, texture, appearance, and preference were evaluated.


    After data collection, a factor analysis of varian- ce (ANOVA) was performed to determine the significant differences in the average evaluation of each rating attribute (aroma, appearance, fla- vor, and texture) across at least two products at a significance level of 0.05. For this purpose, the 13 products subjected to the sensory panel were grouped into two categories according to their sensory qualities, specifically sweet and savory.



    1. Interviews in marketplaces


      The results of the interviews revealed that of the 60 stalls interviewed, only 10 sell chacha fruit, of which 20% claim to sell between 11 and 14 kilos per week; in the case of loquat, of the 60 stalls surveyed, only three stalls sell loquat, of which 33% claim to sell only 3 kilos per week. The cost per kilogram of chacha fruit ranges between

      $6,000 (1.35 USD) and 7,000 pesos (1.56 USD),

      while loquat is between $9,000 (2.03 USD) and

      $12,000 (2.71 USD) per kilogram; these prices vary according to the harvesting season.

      Only 32% of those interviewed claimed to know either of the two species. Of these, 9% know the loquat, and 23% know the chachafruto. Respondents were asked about the names they use to identify these two plant species; for the species Manilkara zapota, 37% said they knew it as sweet sapote, another 37% knew it as loquat, and 13% said they recognized it as zapotilla. On the other hand, the species Erythrina edulis was recognized as Balú (62%), Chachafruto (29%), and 6% recognized it as proto, pites or chugas.


      Regarding the frequency of consumption, 40% of the respondents stated that they consume chacha fruit once a month, followed by special occasions with 27%. As for loquat, 43% stated that they consume it according to its availability in the market.


      As reported by the respondents on the origin of the species, (11.67%) reported that the chacha fruit came from Boyacá, and loquat (5%) reported that it came from the Caribbean zone. Regarding the harvest season for chacha fruit, most interviewees stated that it is grown throughout the year, while the loquat harvest was reported for December (5%) and June (3.33%).

      The most common uses of the two species are human and medicinal consumption. The most popular forms of consumption of chacha fruit are soups and cooked dishes (43%) and sweetened beverages (33%); as for loquat, its most common consumption is associated with juices (72%) and jellies (14%).


    2. Physical and bromatological analysis:


      The results of the physicochemical and bromatological analyses are listed in ( Table 1 ).


      Table 1: Characterization of chacha fruit and Loquat. Source: a. Corzo-Barragán D.C. (2023) b. (Karle Pravin & Dhawale Shashikant, 2019).


      PHYSICAL CHARACTERIZATION


      CHACHAFRUTO

      NESPERO

      Brix degrees

      5.76

      13.0

      pH

      6.5

      5.4

      Firmness (kg/cm2)

      2.46

      5.6

      Edible part (%)

      44

      80

      Total fruit weight (g)

      165.76

      275.4

      Polar diameter (cm)

      4.5

      100.0

      Equatorial diameter (cm)

      2.02

      50.0

      BROMATOLOGICAL CHARACTERIZATION


      CHACHAFRUTOa

      NESPEROb

      % humidity

      84.59

      77.7

      Total ash (g)

      0.94

      0.4

      Crude protein (g)

      19.32

      0.6

      Fiber

      3.5

      3.2


    3. Selection of recipes and transformation techniques applied:


      The selection of recipes was based on the physical aspects of the food, so the application of some transformation techniques would enhance the organoleptic characteristics. The application techniques used are described in ( Table 2 ); a total of 15 products were generated.


      For the selected products, which were transformed using the sugar addition technique, the reference for the production of preserves, as described in NTC 285 of 2007-12-1, on the production of jams, sauces, and jellies, was followed, according to the Brix level that corresponds to the production

      of the product. The formulation was carried out as shown in ( Table 3 ).


      On the other hand, for the preparation of chacha fruit and loquat composite flours (Table 4), the dehydration technique was applied at a temperature of 58 °C for 8 hours for chacha fruit and 15 hours for loquat. The dehydrated food was then processed, and the sample was classified according to ISO 3310-12000 grain size standards, using standard sieves to obtain three samples as follows: sample 1, standard sieve No. 10 with a size of 2.00 mm, sample 2 standard sieve No. 16 with a size of 1.18 mm and sample 3 standard sieve No. 30 with a size of 600µ.


      Angie Dávila1, Diego García, Diana Corzo-Barragán, Carina Gutiérrez Paz, Carlos Carrasco

      Table 2: List of recipes and transformation techniques applied

      Source: Own elaboration.


      Applied preservation and processing technology Chachafruit Loquat


      Fruit sauce

      Fruit sauce

      Sugar addition

      Marmalade

      Marmalade


      Arequipe

      Sandwich


      chacha fruit paste


      Dehydration

      -

      Walleye cookies


      chacha fruit and loquat sandwich (Flour)

      Buñuelos from Antioquia (fruit flour elaboration)


      Yogurt

      Yogurt


      Wrapped (steaming)

      -

      Pulping

      Fritters (Blanching process for mass

      production)

      -

      Scalding

      Pickle

      Chutney


      Table 3: Formulation products processing technique sugar

      addition

      Source: Own elaboration.


      Preparation

      Brix degrees

      Formulation

      Fruit Sauce (chacha fruit and Loquat)

      40°

      40% pulp+40%sugar+20%water

      Loquat Jams

      65°

      50% pulp + 50% sugar

      Loquat Sandwich

      72°

      50%pulp + 50%sugar +1%lemon juice+

      1%pectin


      Table 4: Formulation of composite flours by dehydration

      technique

      Source: Own elaboration.


      Preparation

      Percentage of substitution

      formulation

      Type of sample

      chacha fruit paste

      50%

      50% sour chacha fruit flour

      +50% semolina

      sample 3: standard sieve No.

      30 with 600µ measurement

      chacha fruit cake with medlar snack

      15%

      15% fruit sprout flour + %85 wheat flour

      Sample 2 standard sieve No. 16 with a measurement of

      1.18 mm.

      Loquat Cookies

      25%

      25% Loquat flour + 75%

      wheat flour

      sample 1, standard sieve

      No.10 with a size of 2.00 mm

      Loquat Fritters

      25%

      25% Loquat Flour + 75%

      Corn Starch

      Sample 2 standard sieve No. 16 with a measurement of

      1.18 mm.


      Products were also produced using the technique of pulping the two foods, partially substituting the main product, such as the chacha fruit fritters, where 70% of the bean mass was replaced by chacha fruit puree, chacha fruit wraps with 80% substitution of the corn mass by chacha fruit puree, and loquat chutney with 100% substitution of the main product.

      Regarding the transformation through thermal treatments, two products were developed: chacha fruit cream (prepared by cooking) from a puree and chacha fruit sponge (prepared by refrigeration) from a chacha fruit milkshake for the elaboration of the pickle, scalding, and pH change were used as transformation methods. The product was then laminated with a thickness


      of 3 mm, and subsequently, vinegar and water were added in a proportion of 10% vinegar, 85% water, and 5% salt.


      Other products, such as loquat yogurt, chacha fruit yogurt, and loquat and milk rice, used the fruit sauce of the two foods as an additive ingredient after preparing the yogurt base and as an accompaniment in the case of the milk rice.


    4. Sensory panel


      A sensory sampling of salted products: Figure 1 shows the results of the sensory evaluation of the six products in the salted category concerning four attributes that correspond to organoleptic characteristics of the foods to be evaluated, such as aroma, texture, appearance, and aroma, where there is a clear preference for the chacha fruit fritter, whose rating on the mixed hedonic scale exceeded 4. The product least liked by consumers was the Chacha fruit wrap, whose rating, although the lowest, does not indicate a total rejection in terms of taste, appearance, texture, and aroma. The products with the highest scores concerning the evaluation of the four attributes were the chacha fruit Fritter, the chacha fruit Cream, and the chacha fruit Pickle. On the other hand, the chacha fruit wrap and the chacha fruit paste received the lowest scores, with appearance and texture being the determining factors in the qualification of these two foods.



      Figure 1: Sensory panel results for savory products

      Source: Own elaboration

      A sensory sampling of sweet products: Figure 2 shows the results of the sensory panel associated with the nine products of the sweet category evaluated, considering aroma, appearance, flavor, and texture corresponding to the organoleptic characteristics of the foods evaluated; where the most accepted product in terms of flavor was the chacha fruit roscón followed by loquat chancacas and loquat cookies. On the other hand, chacha fruit yogurt obtained the lowest score, followed by loquat yogurt; however, its score was not less than 3.5 on a scale of 1 to 5, indicating that consumers did not entirely reject the product. In terms of appearance, the sponge received the highest rating, while the chutney received the lowest; the aroma of the roscón received the highest rating, and in terms of texture, the loquat jam was the best rated.


      Figure 2: Sensory panel results sweet preparations

      Source: Own elaboration


      Analysis of Variance by factor (ANOVA)


      A 1-way analysis of variance was applied for each attribute with samples grouped in preparations between salty ( Table6 ) and sweet ( Table7 ) compared in their category ( Table 5 ) with the following results.


      The Table 6 and the Table 7 show that there are significant differences in the sensory evaluation of both savory and sweet products, respectively.






  4. Discussion

    Table 5: Categories of Sweet and Savory Products

    Angie Dávila1, Diego García, Diana Corzo-Barragán, Carina Gutiérrez Paz, Carlos Carrasco


    Sweet Products

    LOQUAT CHUTNEY

    chacha fruit SPONGE

    RICE PUDDING AND LOQUAT

    LOQUAT CHANCACAS

    chacha fruit CAKE AND LOQUAT SNACK

    LOQUAT YOGURT

    chacha fruit YOGURT

    LOQUAT COOKIES

    chacha fruit AREQUIPE


    Savory Products

    chacha fruit WRAP

    chacha fruit FRITTER

    LOQUAT FRITTER

    chacha fruit CREAM

    chacha fruit PASTE

    chacha fruit PICKLE

    Source: Own elaboration.


    Table 6: Analysis of variance: p-value for salted products.

    Sensory evaluation

    p-value

    Decision if a = 5%.

    Appearance

    ~ 0 %

    Significantly different

    Aroma

    ~ 0 %

    Significantly different

    Taste

    0.28 %

    Significantly different

    Texture

    ~0 %

    Significantly different

    Source: Own elaboration.


    Table 7: Analysis of variance: p-value for sweet products.

    Sensory evaluation

    p-value

    Decision if a = 5%.

    Appearance

    0.14 %

    Significantly different

    Aroma

    ~ 0 %

    Significantly different

    Taste

    1.93 %

    Significantly different

    Texture

    1.00 %

    Significantly different

    Source: Own elaboration.



    Ethnobotanical studies are important because they allow knowing the traditional uses that have been given to the species according to the geographical area where they are conducted; in Bogota, they have been conducted in popular markets (marketplaces) where a large number

    of plants are marketed (Giraldo et al., 2015), in their study they describe the traditional use of medicinal plants from the knowledge and practices in eight marketplaces in the city of Bogota, in order to identify promising plants for their therapeutic potential and additionally


    evidence the possible irrational use that could be generated in the community.


    In this research, interviews conducted in Bogotá marketplaces enabled us to determine the number of stalls where these species are commercialized, the quantity of material sold, and the sale price. This exploration allowed us to identify the common names and the most popular uses.


    Rubio et al. (2022) emphasize that the plant species used in gastronomy have elements of cultural heritage, community customs, family relationships, ceremonies, myths, legends, emotions, and scents, among others.


    The proximate analysis carried out in the case of Chachafruto coincides with that reported by Márquez (2021) in terms of moisture and protein parameters. However, the percentage of fiber differs, as this research reported 3.5%, whereas Márquez (2021) reported 8%. Likewise, the percentage of ash presents a difference.


    As for the processing techniques used, the dehydration of the chacha fruit has been carried out in several studies in order to obtain flour, given its nutritional benefits, the methods of adaptation and processing are similar to those carried out by Conda (2021), but for use in dietary supplements in animals, showing promising results in terms of increased bovine milk production.


    For loquat, the results of the bromatological analysis coincide with those reported by Navarro and Vega (2023). In addition, several studies have been conducted on the bioactive compounds present, and they have been used to treat various health symptoms, as they have been reported to be analgesic, anti-inflammatory, and antibacterial (Bashir, 2019).


    Regarding the loquat transformation processes (Kaunsar & Shinwari, 2020), jam production was also carried out to extend the shelf life of

    the raw material and preserve its organoleptic characteristics.


    There is a lack of knowledge about the two species under study, both in the local market and among the participants in the sensory panel, which is exacerbated by the limited supply in the market and high prices. The people marketing these foods often lack accurate information about their origins, harvesting seasons, and production areas.


    The chacha fruit enjoys greater recognition than loquat among respondents in marketplaces, who report that their consumption level is low. As for the nutritional contribution provided by the consumption of chacha fruit, it complements the daily diet's protein intake, as well as the fiber contribution from loquat consumption. The two species evaluated have high gastronomic potential, given their versatility in preparing both sweet and savory dishes. Their transformation through the application of preservation techniques is feasible; however, the low yield of the two foods during the dehydration process can lead to cost overruns in the production of flour- based products. On the other hand, the flavor of chacha fruit is more suitable for the production of salt products, while loquat is more suitable for sweet preparations.


    The sensory panel revealed that both chacha fruit and loquat products received a high level of acceptance from the participants in the two groups that participated in the panel; however, there was a clear preference for loquat products over chachafruit. Of the 15 products submitted to the sensory panel, only three had an average rating below 4: the chacha fruit yogurt, loquat yogurt, and chacha fruit wrap.


    Finally, according to the results, the most popular products were Chachafruto roscones with a loquat sandwich, loquat cookies, and Las Chancacas, indicating a preference for sweet foods, especially among children aged 7 to 13 years.


    Angie Dávila1, Diego García, Diana Corzo-Barragán, Carina Gutiérrez Paz, Carlos Carrasco

  5. Recommendations



    It is recommended to continue researching these species, given their potential, by conducting more detailed studies on their nutritional composition and health effects, as well as exploring the benefits

    they provide and examining the production costs of the proposals presented. It is necessary to carry out socialization campaigns on how to use and benefit from these species to promote their consumption.


  6. Acknowledgments



    To the Fundación Universitaria Cafam and the Jardín Botánico de Bogotá José Celestino Mutis for providing the resources and spaces necessary for the development of this research, to the members of the research team, to the children of the Botanical Garden's science club and the volunteers of the sensory panel for their

    collaboration, good attitude and cooperation in the sensory evaluation of the product, and to the respondents of the marketplaces. We also express our gratitude to the teacher, María Constanza Rodríguez, for her support; her valuable guidance and dedication were indispensable for the successful completion of this research.


  7. References



ANDI (National Association of Colombian Businessmen) (2023). How did food fare in household spending in October 2022? ANDI Alimentos. ANDI. https://www.andi.com.co/ Uploads/2022%20-%2010%20Octubre.pdf


Acero, Duarte, L., Barrera, M. N. & Rodríguez Montenegro, L. (1992). The chacha fruit or Balú, water and soil protector. Human superfood. Forage for livestock. Bogotá D.C.: Fondo para la Protección y Recuperación del Medio Ambiente. https://repository.agrosavia.co/bitstream/ handle/20.500.12324/1902/64156_57083.

pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y


Agronet, Min Agriculture (2023). Chachafruit: everything you need to know about its characteristics and cultivation. Agronet.

https://www.agronet.gov.co/Noticias/Paginas/ Chachafruto-todo-lo-que-necesitas-saber-sobre- sus-caracter%C3%ADsticas-y-cultivo.aspx


Alvarez, D., Espinosa, M. & Urieles, R. (2019). The countryside agonizes: 22 crops are disappearing across the country. El Tiempo https:// www.eltiempo.com/colombia/otras-ciudades/ campo-colombiano-historias-de-cultivos-que- estan-desapareciendo-386222


Bashir, S. (2019). Pharmacological significance of Manilkara zapota and its bioactive constituents. Latin American and Caribbean Bulletin of Medicinal and Aromatic Plants, 18(4), 347-358. https://www.blacpma.ms-editions.cl/index.php/ blacpma/article/view/93


Buitrago-Rueda, N., Ramírez-Villalobos, M., Gómez-Degraves, A., Rivero-Maldonado, G., & Perozo-Bravo, A. (2004). Effect of seed storage and post-sowing light condition on germination and some morphological characteristics of loquat (Manilkara zapota) plants. Journal of the Faculty of Agronomy, 21(4), 343-352. https://produccioncientificaluz.org/index.php/ agronomia/article/view/26505/27131.


Carrillo, G. (2022). Proximal Bromatological Analysis and Determination of Minerals in Loquat (Manilkara zapota), grown at the Experimental and Practical Station of the University of El Salvador [Undergraduate Thesis]. University of El Salvador. https://ri.ues. edu.sv/id/eprint/29176/1/13101782.pdf


Corzo-Barragán, D. C. (2023). Provide professional services to support the Scientific Sub-Directorate in the development of research on potential use and transformation of prioritized plant species, and laboratory support. Unpublished technical report CTO- JBB-134-2023. Bogotá.


Corzo, D. & Plazas, E. (2019). Bromatology and phytochemistry of plant species. Botanical Garden of Bogotá José Celestino Mutis.


Global Forum on Agricultural Research [GFAR] (2011). Global Manifesto on Forgotten Foods. https://www.gfar.net/sites/default/files/ Global%20Manifesto%20on%20Forgotten%20 Foods%20web%20version.pdf.


Giraldo-Quintero, S. E., Bernal-Lizarazú,

M. C., Morales-Robayo, A., Pardo-Lobo, A. Z., & Gamba Molano, L. (2015). Traditional use of medicinal plants in markets in Bogotá, DC. Nova, 13(23), 73–80. http:// www.scielo.org.co/scielo.php?script=sci_ arttext&pid=S1794-24702015000100007


Gonzales-Arce, R. (2008). Of flowers, buds and palm hearts: forgotten foods. Agronomía Costarricense, 32, 183-192. https://www.mag. go.cr/rev_agr/v32n02-183.pdf


Gonzales, X. (2022). The largest seed bank in the

world is in Colombia. (redagricola, Editor) https://

www.redagricola.com/co/el-banco-de-semillas- mas-grande-del-mundo-esta-en-colombia/


Hernández, M., Quiñónez, Y., Torres, M., & Corzo-Barragán, D. C. (2019). Transformation and culinary preparations of high Andean species. Botanical Garden of Bogotá José Celestino Mutis.Botanical Garden of Bogota.


Bogota Botanical Garden launches agroecological seed bank (2022). https://jbb.gov. co/jardin-botanico-de-bogota-lanza-banco-de- semillas-agroecologicas/


Kaunsar, J. & Shinwari, S. R. P. (2020). Rheological and physicochemical properties of a sugar-reduced loquat (Manilkara zapota L.) jam processed under high hydrostatic pressure. Journal of Food Process Engineering, 43, e13388.


Karle-Pravin, P. & Dhawale-Shashikant, C. (2019). Manilkara zapota (L.) Royen Fruit Peel: A Phytochemical and Pharmacological Review. Systematic Reviews in Pharmacy, 10(1), 11-14. https://doi.org/10.5530/srp.2019.1.2. https://doi. org/10.5530/srp.2019.1.2


Ministry of Health and Social Protection, FAO. (2013). Perfil nacional de consumo de frutas y verduras. Bogota D.C.: Ministry of Health and Social Protection. https://www.minsalud.gov. co/sites/rid/Lists/BibliotecaDigital/RIDE/VS/ PP/SNA/perfil-nacional-consumo-frutas-y- verduras-colombia-2013.pdf


Molano, A. (2005). Obtaining and physicochemical and functional characterization of Erythrina edulis (Chachafruit) wholemeal flour for its application as nutritional food. Preliminary design of the production plant. Universidad de los Andes. https://repositorio. uniandes.edu.co/bitstream/handle/1992/22609/ u270833.pdf?sequence=1


Navarro, J. A. & Vega-Figueroa, R. A. (2023). Systematic review of the chemical and nutritional properties of the loquat fruit and leaf Manilkara huberi and its benefits on human health. Universidad del Atlántico, Faculty of Chemistry and Pharmacy.


Angie Dávila1, Diego García, Diana Corzo-Barragán, Carina Gutiérrez Paz, Carlos Carrasco

Prieto, A. & Colonia, A. (2018). Comparative analysis of two drying systems in chacha fruit (Erythrina edulis) leaves. Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira. https://repositorio.utp. edu.co/server/api/core/bitstreams/1e356ede- be75-4258-8228-66d8a3c7e5e6/content


Royen, P. (2007). Manilkara zapota (L.) P. Royen - Sapotaceae. National University of Colombia. http://www.biovirtual.unal.edu.co/en/ collections/result/species/Manilkara%20zapota/ plants/


Rubio-Huerta, L. M., Rodríguez-Corredor, M. A., Cote-Daza, S. P. & Barón-Chivara, J. A. (2022). Market squares as territorial spaces of gastronomic tourism, valuation of typical Bogota gastronomy. Cuadernos de Geografía: Revista Colombiana de Geografía, 31(1), 128-145. https://doi.org/10.15446/rcdg.v31n1.88754.


Torres, M. E. & Corzo-Barragán, D. C. (2019). Transformation and culinary preparations of high Andean species. Bogotá D.C.: Jardín Botánico de Bogotá José Celestino Mutis.